Remember that the only thing that matters is if you like your own car. I don't personally like leather. I never have and I doubt I ever will. I hate leather anything;couches, chairs, trim...you name it.
It looks new for a very small amount of time unless you never use it. Then half of the people who just "must have leather" have cloth seat covers over them.
To be honest I don't buy cars like this for comfort. If I wanted that I'd get a luxury sedan.
I got the leather in my 2010 2SS and I absolutely love it! I have had my car for eight years and have driven it over 200,000 miles and my leather still looks fantastic! There is no way that cloth would ever be able to compare with the durability and nice clean look that my leather seats still have today. After the experience I have had with the leather seats in my Camaro 2SS, I will never own another car without leather seats. I clean them and treat them once in a blue moon… LOL. Seriously, they have been extremely easy to take care of and the effort I have expended has been minimal. I just thought I would let you know about my personal experience with leather seats in the new Camaros.